The Helen Of Troy Theory

by John Werry on May 28, 2009

(Continuation from Part I and Part II)

I’ve been talking a lot about Jenny Lind lately and here’s the impetus for my resurgent interest in solving the mystery of who the carved-arm females are meant to depict:

helen of troy furniture arm The Helen Of Troy Theory

The owner of the sofa had recently put it up for sale on Ebay and an intriguing story came with the set – that it had been bought at the 1876 Philadelphia Centennial Exposition and had stayed in the family it’s entire life until now. The owner had been told by an antiques dealer many years ago that it was part of a parlor design series called “Helen of Troy and Paris”.  Also known as Helen of Sparta, she was the daughter of Zeus and Leda in Greek Mythology.

On the same sofa is the purported Paris (per the antique dealer’s story), Helen’s mythological abductor (or lover depending on what you read).

paris troy The Helen Of Troy Theory

This abduction is the cause of the Trojan War and hers is the “Face That Launched 1,000 Ships” that disembarked to recover her.

In comparing her to historic depictions of Helen of Troy, none are a home-run dead match for the arms:

  1. 1868 bust of Helen by Jean Baptiste Clesinger (Getty Images wants $$ for any use on my site but she is worth a look)
  2. 1788 painting by Jacques-Louis David in the Louvre (both Helen and Paris (in his cap but not helmet))
  3. helen and paris The Helen Of Troy Theory

  4. 1898 depiction by Evelyn de Morgan
  5. helen of troy evelyn de morgan The Helen Of Troy Theory

  6. Vase, 450–440 BC found in Italy (the lines on the headband remind me of those on the sofa)

helen menelaus The Helen Of Troy Theory

The Helen of Troy theory makes some sense.  Some of the carved-arm furniture is of the Neo-Grec sub-style – as is this sofa.

Also, there was a surge of interest in the lost city of Troy in the 1870s due to the excavations of German archaeologist Heinrich Schliemann.  Prior to the 1870s, the city of Troy was considered to be a work of fiction.

The theoretical location of Troy was disputed by academics, but the results of a preliminary dig in 1870 encouraged Schliemann to focus on a manmade mound called Hissarlik (Place OfThe Fortress), and within three years his team of 150 labourers had driven a series of huge trenches through the site, exposing the layers of several cities.
In May 1873, Schliemann spotted gold in one trench. He ordered an early break for lunch and, assisted by his Greek wife Sophie,personally dug up an astonishing hoard of gold, silver and bronze jewellery, together with many priceless ornaments. He smuggled them out of Turkey, an act that sparked fury among Turkish authorities, who understandably felt they had a claim. Priam’s Treasure, as it was called, was exhibited in Berlin’s Bode Museum and made Schliemann a celebrity. He was adept at media manipulation – a drawing of his wife clad in some of the jewelery was reprinted around the world. His Homer theory had been spectacularly vindicated

Also, see this 1870 NY Times article.
Sometime in the early 1870’s, Schliemann’s wife was shown wearing the “Jewels of ….. Helen

jewels of helen The Helen Of Troy Theory

All of this excitement is happening in the years building up to the 1876 Philadelphia Centennial Exposition when this sofa was produced.  Schliemann published Troja und seine Ruinen (Troy and Its Ruins) in 1875.

So What’s the Takeaway?

We have a Neo-Grec sofa with a Greek male figure and a not-so-Greek female.  The apparatus adorning her hair might pass as Greek, but her jabot and tassel seem to be late 19th century attire to me.  Maybe that is a compromise made by the carver so that the sofa would fit better into the parlors of the time.

Paris is often depicted in imagery with a Phyrgian cap, though on this sofa the male profile has a helmet suitable for battle.

The 1870s Neo-Grec furniture had a lot of Greek imagery so it would make sense that male and female depictions would be those of mythology.

We have a story by an “antique dealer” of unknown origin that has followed this sofa through the eons.  We have no way of proving the story, but it would not surprise me to find it to be true (that there was a “Helen of Troy and Paris” series of furniture).

I could find no reference to Jenny Lind playing the part in an Opera of Greek Mythology with a cursory look so I am unaware of the need to depict her in Greek context, espeically since she had faded a bit into home life after the 1850s.

The Schleimann craze in the 1870-1875 surely explains to me the interest in Greek Mythology at the time.

I can’t prove that this is Helen and Paris, but I believe that on this particular sofa (and others of it’s ilk), it is meant to represent a male and female  figure from Greek Mythology, not necessarily Helen and Paris and not Jenny Lind.

I’m not done yet – there are more theories on these carvings left to examine in future posts (some noted by you out there).  But, here’s one last depiction of Helen before we close this particular post out.

bust helen troy The Helen Of Troy Theory

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

RareVictorian June 1, 2009 at 11:14 pm

No one called BS on this yet. Not sure if that is good or bad ;-)

Reply

Robert Lawrence July 30, 2009 at 3:45 pm

The head looks like Richter’s portraits of Queen Louise Augusta, wife of King Frederick William III of Prussia. Her stand against surrendering to Napoleon and her demands for Prussian autonomy and destruction of the French emperor made her the most popular woman in Europe even after her death in the 1850’s and her face was emblazoned on many, many European things, especially German, up through the 1890’s. The crown on the head of your couch image looks just like the head dress Queen Louise usually wore. In Richter’s large and elaborate 1886 drawing of Queen Louise and her two sons she is wearing a cloth head dress of the same shape as those seen in his life portraits. I have a print of Richter’s drawing that dates back to 1886, but the original is in the Cologne Conservatory. How far out in left field is this information?

Reply

Robert Lawrence July 31, 2009 at 11:10 am

Another bit of information on Queen Louise Augusta of Prussia. She was present and dressed as an amazon, wearing the uniform of her lancers, at the battle with Napoleon at Auerstedt. I was incorrect before about her date of death. She died in 1810 and Napoleon’s attempts to slander her even after death made her even more popular in Europe. Napoleon referred to her as “Helen of Troy” because she kept a picture of Czar Nicholas I in her bedroom that made Napoleon claim she was in love with the Russian and not her husband. She was lionized for her great beauty and honored as a heroine up until the turn of the century and after.

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: